A company being unable to see ahead and a company being unable to trust the ground it stands on are two different problems. Yet in management meetings we often explain both with the same word: uncertainty.
We don’t know where sales are heading; we call it uncertainty. We are overly dependent on our largest customer; again we call it uncertainty. We can’t predict how new technology will change our industry. Our organization, where one person makes the critical decisions, can’t function without that person. All of it goes under the same heading.
Yet asking the right question starts with being able to tell these situations apart. Better information about the future of the market does not, on its own, remove a critical dependency inside our company. Making our organization resilient does not automatically show us what the customer will want tomorrow.
To explain this distinction, I put two images side by side:
“I explain VUCA and BANI by putting two metaphors side by side: sailing through a foggy sea and walking on brittle ice. In one, you question how far you can see; in the other, how strong the ground that carries you is.”
— Dr. Hakan Tetik
Sailing through a foggy sea
Imagine you are the captain on a foggy sea. The port you are heading for may be clear. But you can’t see the ship ahead of you, the position of the shore or the approaching danger early enough. The wind is shifting, and the current is pulling you off course. You are trying to make out what the silhouette appearing in front of you is.
In such a situation, the captain’s job is to keep gathering new information while moving forward with what is known. Speed is adjusted to visibility, signals from different sources are compared, and the course is reassessed. Waiting for the fog to lift has its cost; so does going full speed as if visibility were clear.
The volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity of VUCA all find their counterpart in this scene. The shifting wind stands for volatility, the course you can’t see for uncertainty, the conditions affecting one another for complexity, and the silhouette you can’t make out for ambiguity. This is also why the use of fog and navigation imagery in the VUCA literature makes sense. [1]
Walking on brittle ice
Now let us leave the sea and step onto a frozen lake.
The sky is clear. You can see the shore you want to reach. You have no doubt about your direction. But you don’t know how much the ice you are walking on will carry.
Someone having crossed the same spot yesterday is not enough of a guarantee for today. The first few steps going smoothly does not show that the next step is safe either. What’s more, a small extra load can release built-up tension and cause a wide area to break.
Here, better binoculars are of limited use. You need to test the ground, assess the load and create safe options. Even if your balance is perfect, an ice sheet that has exceeded its carrying capacity cannot carry you.
The BANI framework developed by Jamais Cascio highlights brittleness, anxiety, nonlinear relationships and the difficulty of making sense of things. Cascio draws particular attention to the fact that systems that look strong can be brittle. The ice metaphor makes the difference between apparent strength and real resilience tangible. [2]
Knowing that the ice can break creates anxiety. A small step triggering a large break describes the nonlinear effect. Being unable to read the cracks and the carrying capacity underneath by looking at the surface conveys the difficulty of making sense. Of course, this does not mean that ice is physically inexplicable. What the metaphor shows is that we may not have the explanation we need at the moment of decision.
Two separate jobs that complement each other
Thinking about these two images together has an important consequence for management: Seeing the future better and preparing more resiliently for the future are two separate jobs that complement each other.
Consider a hypothetical company. The management team invests in market research, tracks customer trends and prepares scenarios. It develops a strong view of which products will grow in the coming years.
But most of the company’s revenue comes from a single customer. A critical input has no alternative. Only one employee can solve certain problems in production. All important decisions wait on the general manager’s desk.
This company’s visibility may be improving. Its ground, however, is not getting stronger to the same degree.
We can also think of the reverse. A company with a strong cash position, widely shared capabilities and diverse supply options may miss the customer’s changing expectations. While it confidently carries on with its current business, the need for that business may decline.
“What can’t we see?” and “What are we relying on too much?”
This is why the management team needs to ask both “What can’t we see?” and “What are we relying on too much?”
The second question is sometimes more uncomfortable. Because with the first, we talk about gaps in our knowledge of the outside world. With the second, we confront our own choices. We may have tied ourselves to a single supplier for the sake of a cost advantage. We may have centralized decisions to gain speed. While concentrating on a successful product, we may have postponed developing new capabilities.
Each of these choices may be rational under certain conditions. The strategic issue is knowing under which conditions these choices will create brittleness, and taking on that cost consciously.
It is not possible to build a backup against every risk. Trying to keep every option open also scatters resources. That is why strategy requires choice: Which future will we invest in, which dependency will we accept, which alternative will we keep ready and what will we give up?
Planning organizes the chosen future. Strategy chooses which future we will pursue. AI-Powered Dynamic Strategy makes that choice continuously smarter.
Testing assumptions at regular intervals
The continuity here matters. We should test the assumptions underlying our chosen direction at regular intervals. As we link our three-year direction to one-year focus areas, and those focus areas to ninety-day results, we should assess both progress and resilience. As sales grow, is our customer concentration growing too? As delivery speeds up, is our dependence on a single employee increasing? As costs fall, is our room to maneuver in the face of errors shrinking?
These questions allow us to examine the structure behind results that look good.
At the same time, we need to hear the signals coming from the field. The sales team may notice the customer’s hesitation earlier, operations the strain in the process, and middle managers the anxiety of employees. In an organization where this information doesn’t reach the decision table, senior management’s view is limited to what reports can show. Where it is hard to deliver bad news, the cracks become visible late.
Two columns: Visibility and Ground
At your next strategy meeting, I suggest opening two columns. Write “Visibility” on one and “Ground” on the other. In the first column, discuss the most critical unknowns about the future; in the second, your company’s most critical dependencies. Then choose one topic from each column: In the next ninety days, which unknown will you reduce, and which dependency will you ease?
It is not possible to separate VUCA and BANI with sharp boundaries. On a foggy sea, your boat may be brittle; while walking on ice, fog may roll in. My aim in putting these metaphors side by side is to direct the leader’s attention to two places at once: to the future they are moving toward, and to the structure that makes it possible to reach that future.
The view ahead clearing does not mean the ground beneath you has become stronger.
Strategic thinking is being able to read both the fog ahead of you and the cracks beneath you.
Sources
This article draws on the VUCA literature and Jamais Cascio’s BANI framework. The comparative use of the foggy sea and brittle ice metaphors is presented as part of Dr. Hakan Tetik’s approach to strategic thinking.
- Madsen, D. Ø. and Berg, T. (2026), Framing uncertainty: from VUCA to BANI to PUMO in contemporary management discourse, International Journal of Organizational Analysis, 34(12). Open the source.
- Jamais Cascio, Facing the Age of Chaos, April 29, 2020. Open the source.
