The Captain Has Set the Course. But Does the Engine Room Know?

First published in Turkish: Kaptan Rotayı Çizdi. Peki Makine Dairesinin Haberi Var mı?Auf Deutsch lesen

The Captain Has Set the Course. But Does the Engine Room Know?

Imagine that on the bridge the course has been set, the destination port chosen and the arrival time calculated. The captain gives the order: “Full speed ahead!” – But the ship does not move.

First the order is repeated. Then voices rise. Then everyone looks at one another: The course is clear, the destination is clear, the instruction is clear. So why aren’t we moving?

Some of the problems companies run into when implementing strategy can be described with this scene. Senior management makes important decisions about the future. Priorities are set, presentations are prepared, targets are announced. When the expected movement fails to appear after a while, the question comes up: “Why isn’t the organization implementing the strategy?”

Before asking that question, we need to go down to the engine room.

The engine room of strategy

I see middle managers as the engine room of strategy. Because this is largely where the company’s choices about the future turn into employees’ daily decisions, relationships with customers, the use of resources and operational results. The direction set on the bridge turns into movement here.

But this analogy has an important limit: Middle managers are not mechanical parts that work when a button is pressed. They think, interpret, see risks and generate options. That is why a management that expects only power from the engine room cannot make enough use of the knowledge that accumulates there.

The distance between announcing and owning

There is an important distance between a strategy being announced and being owned. Attending the presentation, learning the targets and nodding at the end of the meeting do not show that this distance has been covered. If a manager has not understood the rationale for the chosen direction, cannot see their own unit’s contribution, or does not know how to decide when priorities conflict, the strategy may remain, for them, an expectation added on top of daily work.

Steven Floyd and Bill Wooldridge’s 1992 study Managing Strategic Consensus draws attention to middle management’s problems of understanding and commitment in implementing strategy. The distinction here is valuable: A manager may understand the strategy but not believe in it; may support it but misinterpret what is expected of them. That is why saying “We explained it to everyone” is not enough to show that shared understanding and commitment have formed. [1]

This is what I mean when I say, “Middle management must buy into the strategy.” Buying in does not mean the manager agrees unconditionally with every decision. It means grasping the logic of the choice, being able to voice objections, and taking on their own responsibility once the decision has been made. For this ownership to form, the manager should have an answer to this question: “Do I know why this direction is right for the company and what I need to change here?”

At what stage do we bring middle management in?

This raises a harder question that senior management needs to ask itself: At what stage of strategic thinking do we bring middle management in?

Gathering managers in a room once decisions are complete, budgets are committed and priorities are finalized narrows the space in which they can contribute. Yet the people who live with customer objections, the real capacity of processes, teams’ skill gaps and the friction between different units are an important source of information for testing the strategy’s assumptions. If this information reaches the table while the decision is being formed, some implementation problems can be seen before they even arise.

Of course, not every strategic decision needs to be open to everyone’s approval. The limits of participation and decision rights should be clear. Senior management bears the responsibility for choosing the direction and allocating resources. Middle management contributes to evaluating alternatives, testing assumptions and developing implementation choices. It may not be possible to accept every view; but explaining how the views were evaluated makes participation meaningful.

Cascading the strategy

Cascading the strategy should be approached with the same understanding. In a good cascading process, as the message reaches every layer of the organization, it gains concrete counterparts in decisions at each layer.

For example, let us imagine a company that has chosen to grow through customized solutions. The sales manager needs to know which customers to focus on, which requests to turn down and what value proposition to offer. The production manager should assess what this means for flexibility, capacity and delivery time. The human resources manager, in turn, should see which skills the new direction requires. Everyone can repeat the same strategic sentence; the real issue is for that sentence to turn into decisions that support one another.

What’s more, if the old success measures are kept unchanged while the new strategy is being announced, the manager may face conflicting expectations. They may be asked to produce customized solutions while being evaluated only on transaction speed. They may be expected to collaborate across units while their bonus is tied solely to their own department’s results. In such a situation, asking them to own the strategy does not remove the contradiction in the management system.

A management that expects commitment to the strategy must also make behavior aligned with the strategy possible.

This requires talking about what will be given up, not only about priorities. Which work will stop for the sake of the new direction? Which requests will be postponed? Which resources will be shifted to other areas? It is easy to add new targets to a middle manager’s already full agenda. The real strategic choice becomes visible when deciding what to make room for on that agenda.

The relationships managers build among themselves

Another dimension of cascading is the relationships managers build among themselves. Julia Balogun and Gerry Johnson’s 2004 qualitative study, which followed a restructuring process, shows the importance of middle managers’ lateral interactions in how they make sense of change. It would not be right to draw firm conclusions for all companies from a single organizational context. But the study reminds us that the meaning of a strategy is shaped not only by official announcements but also by conversations among managers. [2]

That is why a launch meeting is not enough to cascade a strategy. Managers need to work through shared cases, discuss priority conflicts and understand each other’s dependencies. Saying “We are customer-focused” is easy. Agreeing together on which principle applies when an important customer’s urgent request disrupts the production plan takes more effort.

Information flowing back from the engine room to the bridge

The information that flows back from the engine room to the bridge is also part of this process. It may turn out that the chosen customer group behaves differently than expected, that a capacity assumption does not hold, or that a new opportunity has emerged. When middle management can pass these on, strategy learns from implementation. In an environment where every warning is interpreted as resistance, however, senior management risks losing the information that would improve its decisions.

In return, middle management must also take responsibility. Making constraints visible, developing solution options, explaining the rationale for decisions to their teams and following up on results are part of this role. Having a say in strategic decisions also requires owning their consequences.

A stronger check

At the next strategy meeting, alongside measuring how many people the presentation reached, we can add a stronger check: Let us ask a middle manager to explain the company’s core choice in their own words, to name one piece of work they will stop because of this choice, and to explain what information from the field could change our decision. Their answers will show how far the strategy has taken root in day-to-day management.

The captain setting the course is the beginning of the voyage. To move forward, the engine room needs to understand this course, generate the movement and carry what it sees along the way back up to the bridge.

In your company, is middle management waiting for the strategy to be explained to it, or is it able to contribute to how the strategy forms and evolves?

Sources

  1. Floyd, S. W. and Wooldridge, B. (1992). Managing strategic consensus: the foundation of effective implementation. Academy of Management Executive, 6(4), 27–39. Open the source.
  2. Balogun, J. and Johnson, G. (2004). Organizational Restructuring and Middle Manager Sensemaking. Academy of Management Journal, 47(4), 523–549. Open the source.

Cite as: Tetik, H. (2026). The Captain Has Set the Course. But Does the Engine Room Know? hakantetik.com. https://www.hakantetik.com/en/blog/the-captain-has-set-the-course-does-the-engine-room-know

A keynote, a workshop or a transformation program. Let's find the right starting point.

Speaking and advisory engagements are available in English and German as well as Turkish.

hakant@4biz.com.tr
Write to me